South Carolina scored 116 points against FGCU, recorded a program-record 38 points in the second quarter, and received contributions from all 13 active players. The performance offered more than a comfortable win. It raised a difficult question for Dawn Staley as the Gamecocks prepare for Providence and a major matchup against UConn: how should she manage a roster that appears to have more productive options than available minutes?
Chloe Kitts’ expected return adds another layer to the discussion. South Carolina already demonstrated how effective its offense can be without her, particularly with Agot Makeer directing the attack and Joyce Edwards operating aggressively around the basket. Kitts remains an important part of the rotation, but her return could change the roles that several players established during her absence.
Kitts’ return could change the offensive balance
Kitts did not play against FGCU because South Carolina elected to give her additional rest. She had played 34 minutes against USC after returning from an ACL injury, and the coaching staff was careful about her workload. Dawn Staley has made it clear that Kitts’ availability depends on the medical team and the player herself.
Her potential return against Providence would give South Carolina another experienced interior option. Kitts has recorded three consecutive double-doubles since returning, and her value extends beyond scoring. She rebounds, passes from the high post, and helps organize the half-court offense.
The question is how the team adjusts around her.
Against FGCU, Makeer handled more of the offensive responsibility. She scored 17 points, recorded six assists, and committed just one turnover. Her ability to control the offense was particularly encouraging because South Carolina needed another player capable of creating opportunities when the primary options were unavailable.
Against USC, however, Makeer’s role was different. She scored nine points, struggled with turnovers, and fouled out. The contrast illustrates how her responsibilities change depending on the lineup and the defensive pressure she faces.
Kitts and Makeer can both start. The real question concerns who controls the offense when they share the floor.
Joyce Edwards could be the biggest beneficiary
Edwards has shown that she can play different roles depending on the personnel around her.
With Kitts against USC, Edwards focused more on defensive rebounding and passing. She recorded only one offensive rebound. Against FGCU, she attacked the glass more aggressively, collected six offensive rebounds, and finished 10 of 14 from the field.
That version of Edwards creates serious problems for opposing defenses. She runs the floor, attacks missed shots, and finishes efficiently near the basket.
Her performance against Clemson also showed why South Carolina needs to manage her responsibilities carefully. When the half-court offense became crowded, Edwards carried a larger share of the possessions but struggled with efficiency.
Kitts’ return could allow Edwards to remain aggressive without requiring her to create every possession herself. Whether she continues attacking the offensive glass or assumes a more conservative role will be one of the most important adjustments to watch.
Her free-throw shooting also deserves attention. Edwards is currently shooting 45.5% from the line, compared with 70.7% last season. That number is likely to improve, but South Carolina would benefit from a correction before the UConn game.
The battle for the eighth rotation spot is becoming interesting
South Carolina’s depth may create one of Staley’s most difficult rotation decisions of the season.
Ashlyn Watkins remains a major defensive presence. Her shot-blocking ability helped South Carolina generate transition opportunities against FGCU, and she gives the team a different physical dimension around the rim.
Alicia Tournebize also made an impressive return. She finished with 14 points and 13 rebounds in only 13 minutes. Eight of those rebounds came on the offensive end, which makes her performance particularly difficult to ignore.
Meanwhile, Ayla McDowell offers a different skill set. Her shooting ability provides spacing, and she has been productive in limited minutes.
The decision may depend on the opponent. Tournebize provides size, rebounding, and rim protection. McDowell offers shooting that could make the offense more difficult to defend when the paint becomes crowded.
Staley has generally used a shorter rotation against ranked opponents. The core group has included Tessa Johnson, Edwards, Makeer, Jordan Lee, Kitts, Jersey Robinson, and Watkins. The eighth position could become a matchup-dependent decision.
That competition matters because South Carolina is preparing for opponents that will demand different offensive and defensive adjustments.
Tessa Johnson is playing at an elite level
Johnson has been one of South Carolina’s most reliable offensive players. She scored a career-high 28 points against USC and has continued to shoot efficiently from three-point range.
Makeer has also been productive from the perimeter, which gives South Carolina two players capable of stretching defenses. That combination becomes particularly valuable if opposing teams attempt to crowd Edwards and Kitts inside.
Jordan Lee, however, needs a stronger performance. Her shooting numbers have been below expectations, and the competition for closing minutes is becoming more serious.
Robinson had a difficult shooting night against FGCU, but her contribution remained valuable. She finished with 11 rebounds, six assists, and zero turnovers. Those numbers demonstrate why shooting alone does not determine her place in the rotation.
South Carolina has options. The challenge for Staley is finding the combinations that work best in close games.
Providence presents an opportunity before the UConn test
Providence enters the matchup with a 2–3 record. The Friars have struggled offensively, averaging 60.2 points per game while shooting 42.2% from the field. Their perimeter shooting has been particularly poor, with 15 made three-pointers on 79 attempts.
Their leading scorer is a junior point guard averaging 15.6 points per game. She will be the primary player South Carolina must contain. Providence also has size in the frontcourt, including 6-foot-4 transfer Jayodora Young, but the team has struggled to maintain consistent production across its roster.
Turnovers could be another major problem. Providence averages 18 per game, and its assist-to-turnover ratio has been particularly concerning. South Carolina’s defensive pressure could create easy scoring opportunities if the Friars struggle to protect the ball.
The Gamecocks should also have a significant advantage on the boards. Their offensive rebounding has been one of the strongest aspects of the recent performance, and Providence will need to limit second-chance opportunities to remain competitive.
South Carolina defeated Providence 96–55 last season. A similar result is possible if the Gamecocks control the paint, pressure the ball, and maintain their offensive efficiency.
The real test comes on Tuesday
Providence is an important opportunity for South Carolina to establish its rotation before facing UConn. The coaching staff will have to decide how many minutes Kitts receives, how Makeer operates alongside her, and which players deserve extended opportunities.
The matchup also gives Edwards another chance to establish her offensive role. Watkins and Tournebize could provide valuable minutes inside, while Johnson and Makeer offer shooting that can open the floor.
South Carolina has the talent to win comfortably. The more important objective is to leave Providence with a rotation that Staley trusts against a top-level opponent.
Prediction: South Carolina 94, Providence 48.
The Gamecocks should control the game from the opening quarter. Providence’s shooting struggles and turnover problems create a favorable matchup, while South Carolina’s depth gives Staley several ways to manage the game.
The biggest question remains the lineup.
Will Kitts return to the starting five and allow Makeer to continue directing the offense? Or will Staley use Watkins alongside Edwards and keep Kitts in a more controlled role before Tuesday?
That decision could tell us a great deal about how South Carolina plans to approach the remainder of the season.