The Detroit Lions’ 2025 NFL draft class is getting hammered by analytics—and not in a good way. According to data-based evaluations, Detroit ranks near the bottom of the league in draft efficiency, with multiple experts citing poor value, questionable trade decisions, and a failure to address critical needs early.
Lions’ 2025 draft decisions criticized for lack of value and position strategy
The Lions walked away from the 2025 draft with seven new players, but many analysts believe they paid too steep a price for too little return. A consensus grading chart compiled by Rene Bugner placed Detroit tied for second-worst among 32 teams, earning a dismal grade point average that matched the Miami Dolphins and barely edged out the Cincinnati Bengals.
Analytics-driven draft grade delivers rare “F” to Lions’ front office
One of the harshest reviews came from The Athletic’s Austin Mock, who leverages a purely analytical model to grade draft classes. Mock issued the Lions an “F”—one of only four such grades league-wide—citing multiple reaches in the top 70 picks and poor trade value, especially in the move up to select wide receiver Isaac TeSlaa.
According to Mock’s metrics, Detroit lost the fourth-most value in draft-day trades. By comparison, teams with similar or worse trade grades at least secured premium players like Travis Hunter or additional first-round picks.
Top 2025 Lions draft picks labeled as “reaches” by consensus boards
Of Detroit’s top three selections, all were considered significant overreaches. This suggests a disconnect between the Lions’ internal scouting priorities and league-wide evaluations. Critics argue that Detroit failed to capitalize on higher-value prospects and instead made aggressive moves for players they could have likely acquired later.
Lack of edge rusher pick raises red flags for Detroit’s pass rush
Perhaps the most glaring hole in the Lions’ 2025 draft strategy is the absence of a top-tier edge rusher. Detroit waited until the sixth round to address the position, despite it being a known weakness on the roster. In a division loaded with strong offensive lines, the decision not to prioritize pass rush help could haunt them.
Brad Holmes’ draft record still earns benefit of the doubt—for now
While the analytics community may be slamming Detroit’s draft haul, general manager Brad Holmes remains one of the most respected draft architects in the league. Since taking over in 2021, Holmes has drafted several cornerstone players who’ve gone on to sign lucrative second contracts. His track record has created a level of trust that tempers even the harshest criticism.
Still, this draft class is testing that goodwill. If the 2025 picks underperform, particularly Isaac TeSlaa and the top-three selections, it could mark a significant misstep in Holmes’ tenure.
FAQ: Lions 2025 NFL Draft Class Review
Why did the Lions receive such a low draft grade in 2025?
Analytics models criticized the team for overreaching on picks and losing significant value in draft-day trades.
Who was considered the biggest reach by Detroit in the 2025 draft?
Wide receiver Isaac TeSlaa, acquired after a costly trade-up, was widely seen as the most questionable move.
Did the Lions address their need for an edge rusher?
Not effectively. They didn’t draft an edge rusher until the sixth round, despite it being a major area of need.
Are these criticisms final?
No. While analytics grades evaluate process and value, player performance on the field will ultimately determine the success of the draft class.
